The all-time Indianapolis Colts roster is loaded. Under center it's Peyton Manning, Marshall Faulk carries the load, and Marvin Harrison leads the receivers. Below is the greatest Colts team ever assembled, with every player rated exactly as they appear in 17-0 — the free game where you draft an all-time roster and simulate whether it can finish a perfect 17-0 season.
Think this Colts squad could run the table? Build your own all-time team, position by position, and find out.
All-time starting lineup
Best Colts at every position · rating out of 100
- QBPeyton Manning
Quarterback · 2000s98 - RBMarshall Faulk
Running Back · 1990s90 - WRMarvin Harrison
Wide Receiver · 2000s93 - TEJohn Mackey
Tight End · 1960s90 - OLJim Parker
Offensive Line · 1960s92 - DLDwight Freeney
Defensive Line · 2000s90 - LBDarius Leonard
Linebacker · 2010s88 - DBBob Sanders
Defensive Back · 2000s89
Deep roster
More of the best Colts by position
Quarterback
Johnny Unitas (97) · Andrew Luck (86) · Bert Jones (78) · Jeff George (76)
Running Back
Edgerrin James (89) · Jonathan Taylor (87) · Eric Dickerson (86) · Frank Gore (82)
Wide Receiver
Raymond Berry (88) · Reggie Wayne (86) · T.Y. Hilton (83) · Michael Pittman Jr. (78)
Tight End
Dallas Clark (82) · Raymond Chester (74) · Coby Fleener (74) · Marcus Pollard (74)
Offensive Line
Quenton Nelson (92) · Ryan Kelly (83) · Will Wolford (82) · Tarik Glenn (82)
Defensive Line
Robert Mathis (84) · DeForest Buckner (84) · Bubba Smith (82) · Grover Stewart (80)
Linebacker
Ted Hendricks (86) · Shaquille Leonard (85) · Mike Curtis (82) · Zaire Franklin (80)
Defensive Back
Ray Buchanan (81) · Antoine Bethea (80) · Kenny Moore II (78) · Stephon Gilmore (78)
Can this team go 17-0?
Draft your own all-time roster and simulate a perfect season.
🏈 Play 17-0 freeEvery franchise
Explore all-time rosters for all 32 teams