Who is the best quarterback in Colts history? Here are the top 12, ranked by their rating in 17-0 — the free game where you draft an all-time roster and simulate whether it can go a perfect 17-0 season. Peyton Manning (2000s) tops the list at 98.
The ranking
Best Colts quarterbacks ever · rating out of 100
- 1Peyton Manning
Colts · 2000s98 - 2Johnny Unitas
Colts · 1960s97 - 3Andrew Luck
Colts · 2010s86 - 4Bert Jones
Colts · 1970s78 - 5Jeff George
Colts · 1990s76 - 6Philip Rivers
Colts · 2020s76 - 7Jim Harbaugh
Colts · 1990s74 - 8Matt Ryan
Colts · 2020s74 - 9Anthony Richardson
Colts · 2020s72 - 10Jacoby Brissett
Colts · 2010s72 - 11Matt Hasselbeck
Colts · 2010s72 - 12Gardner Minshew
Colts · 2020s71
Draft your all-time team
Nine picks, offense to defense. Can your roster go a perfect 17-0?
🏈 Play 17-0 freeMore Colts all-time
Every position, plus the full Colts roster
Best Colts Running BacksBest Colts Wide ReceiversBest Colts Tight EndsBest Colts LinebackersBest Colts Defensive BacksColts All-Time Roster
Best quarterbacks by team
The same ranking for other franchises
49ers QuarterbacksBears QuarterbacksBengals QuarterbacksBills QuarterbacksBroncos QuarterbacksBrowns QuarterbacksBuccaneers QuarterbacksCardinals QuarterbacksChargers QuarterbacksChiefs QuarterbacksCommanders QuarterbacksCowboys QuarterbacksDolphins QuarterbacksEagles QuarterbacksFalcons QuarterbacksGiants QuarterbacksJaguars QuarterbacksJets QuarterbacksLions QuarterbacksOilers QuarterbacksPackers QuarterbacksPanthers QuarterbacksPatriots QuarterbacksRaiders QuarterbacksRams QuarterbacksRavens QuarterbacksSaints QuarterbacksSeahawks QuarterbacksSteelers QuarterbacksTexans QuarterbacksTitans QuarterbacksVikings Quarterbacks
Best by position
League-wide all-time rankings